How Dietary Survey Methods Affect Intake Estimates

Dietary survey methods

In collaboration with The World Bank, GDD team members found that estimating individual dietary intake from household consumption overestimated true individual dietary intake by up to 240%

Types of Dietary Data Collection Methods

Even modest dietary changes are associated with improvements in health, particularly in mothers, children, and other populations vulnerable to undernutrition and micronutrient deficiencies. Consequently, these populations are often the target of nutrition interventions and policies, which greatly rely on accurate dietary data to maximize their effectiveness.

Currently, the most consistently-accurate dietary data collection tool is the 24-hour recall (24hR), in which a trained professional systematically interviews subjects about their food intake from the previous day. Unfortunately, its requirement for trained professionals makes 24hR slow and costly to administer, making them impractical for populations with limited access to funding. For populations like these, preferred tools are ones that can be deployed quicker and at a lower cost.

One such tool is a household consumption survey, in which a single respondent provides information on the entire household’s food consumption over a given period, rather than distinguishing intake by each individual household member. Researchers then use these responses to extrapolate intake of each household member using one of two calculations: the Per-Capita (PC) method, which assumes intake is symmetrical across the household, or the preferred Adult Male Equivalent (AME) method, which takes members’ age and sex into account when distributing intake estimates. However, research from GDD team members found that both approaches are still far from perfect.

How Methods Drive Estimates

In a recent study, Karageorgou et al. found that, even when using the AME approach, household consumption surveys overestimated true individual intakes of almost all foods when compared to 24hR. This overestimation was especially pronounced in children and low socioeconomic households (both of which are vulnerable populations) as well as nutrient-dense foods like fruits, vegetables, and animal-source products. These differences in turn drove overestimates of key micronutrients like Vitamin A, folate, and calcium -- all of which are commonly the focus of nutrition interventions in vulnerable populations.

These discrepancies have wide-reaching implications. First, they may indicate the lack of caretakers' awareness of true dietary intake in children, which can ultimately contribute to their malnutrition. Furthermore, if these inaccurate estimates are informing dietary interventions or policies, it's possible that valuable time and resources are being misplaced or wasted entirely.

These findings highlight the need for more precise ways to estimate individual dietary intake from household consumption data, especially for children. By prioritizing accurate dietary assessment, particularly in low- and middle-income residences, the global nutrition community can formulate more reliable burden analyses, interventions, and policies.

Household consumption survey overestimation chart

 

Comments

Submitted by sophya87 on Mon, 09/11/2023 - 05:38

Permalink

Surely you only know New York as a place of America, right? But now there is one more great game genre that you should experience: nytimes crossword

Submitted by dekador on Thu, 10/05/2023 - 13:14

Permalink

Achieving high levels of student engagement can be a challenge for educators. Effective learning strategies Ox Essays reviews enhance student engagement fostering a dynamic and participatory learning environment.

Submitted by dekador on Thu, 11/16/2023 - 15:15

Permalink

Hosting a chocolate themed event is a surefire way to create an atmosphere of indulgence, delight, and sophistication. Whether you opt for interactive activities or a lavish adult chocolate buffet the versatility of chocolate allows for endless creative possibilities.

Submitted by priyanka plus on Tue, 12/05/2023 - 04:51

Permalink

Our team will certainly make you really feel at ease, talk to you in a humble manner, flirt with you, and make you really feel delighted. They are fluent in the art of impressing a lusty person, and because of this, we can ensure you the highest degree of high quality time with our Escort in Ranchi. Every one of the call ladies in Ranchi have substantial training and experience in the sector. 

Submitted by rishu01 on Wed, 12/06/2023 - 01:33

Permalink

Most of the passionate and unsatisfied college Greater Kailash Escorts are willingly working with us for their own pleasure. You can spread your arms around their lascivious figure and play with their big breasts till the dawn. Call us now.

Submitted by kaabir01 on Wed, 12/06/2023 - 06:43

Permalink

Her wardrobe is full of costly things and branded clothes. She always wants t attracted rich people so that she always tries to look perfect. They all are materialistic and shopping freak. Escorts in Greater Kailash Not all men are lucky to have a beautiful girlfriend but all are fantasized that they have good looking, hot, stunning girlfriend and make their life spicy and they will the king for the night.

Submitted by ahmed saa sasaas on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 02:56

Permalink

Explore the limitless possibilities of creativity with our innovative tools and resources. Unleash your imagination and elevate your projects to new heights. Click here to embark on a journey of inspiration and transformation."

Submitted by Walkeaze Shoes on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 04:51

Permalink

Walkeaze offers its customer the best quality Shoulder bag for women and girls online. Explore the latest collection of shoulder bags online at Walkeaze. Grab your favorite fashionable bags for girls and women at low prices.

Submitted by Mohagni on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 05:31

Permalink

Discover the beautiful world of silk dress designs by Mohagni. Our collection reflects incredible craftsmanship, rich textiles and timeless elegance. Elevate your style with our unique stunning silk dresses. Explore the latest Mohagni collections now and embrace the beauty of silk fashion.

Submitted by chahyay on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 05:41

Permalink

Find the perfect Luxury Pret at Chahyay. Browse our collection and get the best Quality Pret dresses that will make you shine at any event. Shop now.

Submitted by jazminpk on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 05:53

Permalink

Explore the best collection of shawls for women in Pakistan. Our shawls, which range in style from classic to modern, are handmade with the finest fabrics and great attention to detail. Our latest collection of shawls can help you stay warm in winter Season. Get a perfect item that combines style and warmth right now by shopping.

Submitted by Borjan on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 06:28

Permalink

Borjan presents the best collection of formal shoes online in Pakistan. Explore the variety of men's formal shoes online at Borjan. Grab your favorite shoes online at affordable prices today.

Submitted by ecs on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 06:40

Permalink

ECS is presenting the best women heels shoes collections online in Pakistan. Our heels for females are trendy and premium quality products. We also offer the best design for women's heels shoes online, which are exclusively the best quality products.

Submitted by servis shoes on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 06:45

Permalink

Get the best running shoes online from Servis. Discover the best quality running shoes and jogging shoes online at Servis. So, grab your shoes at low prices today.

Submitted by The Entertainer on Thu, 12/07/2023 - 07:38

Permalink

Unlock your child creativity with a vibrant array of color pencils, crayon colors, and more at The Entertainer. Our extensive collection ensures you'll find the perfect shades to bring your imagination to life. Shop now and let your children artistic talents shine!

Submitted by soniyasinghania on Fri, 12/08/2023 - 04:08

Permalink

Are you looking for gorgeous as well as sensational Jhunjhunu Call Girls tonight? If of course, our Jhunjhunu Call girls are always all set to be with you in your house/ hotel for an outstanding experience. The crackling hot call girls in Jhunjhunu are outstanding at various occasions and celebrations. They can be your girlfriend as well as performer to bring excitement to the session.

Submitted by Ardenboehm on Sun, 01/14/2024 - 23:14

Permalink

Thank you for providing such useful information. I've been having trouble coming up with many questions about this topic. I'll stick with you!  wordle hint

Submitted by Shweta Roy on Tue, 01/23/2024 - 07:41

Permalink

Most of the independent Baga Beach Call Girls are working with an international organization and they hardly get time for this. These call girls have been dissatisfied for a long time and seeking a real partner who could satisfy their hunger. If you love to go wild on the bed think you have got your carbon copy. Passionate independent Call Girls are famous for their wildness on the Bed.

Submitted by sophya87 on Fri, 01/26/2024 - 03:09

Permalink

I value your submission. I have extensively studied numerous interconnected topics. In contrast to other articles, yours left me with a highly distinctive impression. I anticipate that you will continue producing perceptive articles, such as this one, for the benefit of all readers. trap the cat

Submitted by Suman01 on Thu, 02/01/2024 - 01:56

Permalink

However, your enjoyment is not complete unless you enjoy the company of one or more Russian Goa Escort Service. But such girls are not readily available for heavenly and inexplicable bliss, and they can only be obtained from our escort service.